The Shift to GEO
How AI is changing search marketing and what businesses actually need to know…
I’ve been doing SEO for over 13 years, and this is one of the most exciting times I’ve experienced in the industry. It’s also one of the most uncertain.
For the past 10+ years, SEO has been pretty much the same. Sure, there were minor algorithm changes, but the fundamentals stayed consistent. Now? Everything’s different. And I mean everything.
The numbers are wild: projections show that within a couple of years, LLMs like ChatGPT and Perplexity will get more traffic than Google’s organic search results. We’re not talking about some distant future. This is happening right now.
What I’m Actually Seeing with Our Clients
Our clients are noticing changes, and they’re asking a lot of questions. Some are concerned, and understandably so.
Here’s what they’re telling us:
- Organic search traffic has been dropping consistently over the past year or two. Not massive 50% drops, but enough to notice.
- Lower engagement and conversions because of that reduced traffic
- Customers mentioning they found them through ChatGPT or other AI tools
Just last week, I went to a networking event with about 500 people. I talked to maybe 30 of them, and roughly half were asking about AI optimization and these changes in SEO. There’s huge appetite for understanding this stuff, but most people have no idea where to start.
The thing is, even for someone like me. I’ve been technical my whole career, started in web development before getting into SEO. I live and breathe this stuff daily – and I’m still figuring it out. Every single day I learn something new about how this is changing.
The Good News: The Fundamentals are the Same
Here’s what surprised me when we started diving deep into Generative Enging Optimization (GEO): it’s built on the same principles as regular SEO.
When someone asks ChatGPT or Claude a question, the AI still looks for the same things we’ve always optimized for:
- Semantic relevance
- Topical authority
- Well-formatted, accessible content
- Backlinks and other authority signals
What’s really interesting is that we’re seeing sites that were huge in the early days of SEO become important again. Wikipedia is a source for about 50% of ChatGPT’s responses. Reddit accounts for almost 20%. Yelp is big too.
These were the authoritative sites that mattered when SEO was young, became less critical over the years, and now they’re back. It’s almost like we’re going back to early SEO again, because these AI systems are still figuring out their algorithms.
How We’re Adapting Our Team
We’ve always been big on training because digital marketing moves fast. Even before AI gained prominence, but it’s now more critical than ever.
The main thing we look for in team members is a growth mindset. Too many people get comfortable, go through the motions, don’t challenge themselves because they’re afraid of failing. But if you want to grow, you have to step outside that comfort zone and try new things.
We do “Training Thursdays,” send people to conferences (our director of search is recently attended a GEO conference in Austin, Texas), and we’re always looking for new certifications and learning opportunities.
The key is giving people permission to experiment. Want to try a new tool? Go for it. Try it for a few months, see if it works. If it does, maybe we get more team members on it.
The Tools We’re Actually Using
AI has definitely changed how we work, but we had to be smart about implementation.
Content Creation Yes, AI makes content development way faster. But we learned quickly that if you just spin out content from ChatGPT and paste it, you look unprofessional. We developed strict policies around how to use it properly and stay transparent with clients about when and how we’re using AI.
Protecting Client Data One big concern was confidentiality. Say someone’s working on a Google Ads campaign and wants to quickly put together a report. We didn’t want them grabbing confidential client information and dropping it into some random AI tool where we don’t know where that data goes or how it’s stored.
So we built our own data anonymizer. Our team can input information, strip out any client data, and then use the AI safely. It protects our clients while still letting us work efficiently.
Existing Tools Getting Better Our existing tools have been adding AI features, which has been great. Like Apollo, which we use for sales outreach—they added an automated workflow builder that can build prospect lists automatically. Something that used to take forever is now automated. When that happens across multiple tools, it really compounds.
What’s Coming Next
The most exciting thing happening right now is that we finally have tools to measure this stuff. We just started using software that can do a full brand audit across different LLMs. We can see how a client performs versus competitors, what factors are making them show up (or not), and where their content gaps are.
This is still early days, but having actual measurement tools makes it feel less experimental and more strategic.
What Business Owners Should Actually Do
Based on working with dozens of clients through this shift, here’s my honest advice:
Don’t panic about traditional SEO. The fundamentals still matter. The same things that make your content good for Google make it valuable for AI systems.
Focus on quality content. Not keyword-stuffed articles, but content that actually helps people. AI systems are getting better at recognizing authority and usefulness.
Start paying attention to where your brand shows up in AI responses. Ask ChatGPT questions related to your industry and see if you appear. If you don’t, that’s something to work on.
Stay educated. This field changes daily. Whether that’s through your own learning, networking events, or working with an agency that stays on top of this stuff, you need to keep up.
The Reality Check
Despite all these changes, marketing still comes down to basics: knowing your value proposition, understanding your customers, and solving real problems.
Whether someone finds you through Google or ChatGPT, when they land on your website, your content better be good enough to get them to contact you or buy something. You can’t just spin out AI content and paste it—you have to spend time making sure you’re actually selling your product or service and getting people to take action.
It always comes back to the fundamentals.
Where We Stand
We launched our GEO services recently, and being full transparent we are building while flying. Things are moving quickly! We know businesses have questions, and we’re doing our best to help them work through these challenges.
The companies that’ll do well are the ones that stay curious, try new things, but don’t lose sight of what actually drives results: creating value for customers and making it easy for them to choose you.